Time-of-Use Electricity Rates: How They Work and Whether Switching Pays
A time-of-use electricity rate charges more per kWh during a daily peak window. It pays off when most of your usage falls outside that window.
- Break-even formula
- Real plan prices
- Sources linked
Peak prices on a time-of-use (TOU) plan typically run two to three times the off-peak price. Households with an EV, a pool pump or nobody home on weekday afternoons usually win; a home that runs air conditioning hard at 5 pm every day can end up paying more.
This guide covers how the plans are built, the kinds you will be offered, who saves and who does not, and a five-minute calculation that answers the switching question with your own bill. For the actual peak windows and prices at seven large utilities, see peak and off-peak electricity hours; this page assumes you have a sense of what your utility's window is.
How a time-of-use rate works
Every residential electricity bill multiplies kWh by a price. On a flat rate there is one price. On a TOU rate the day is cut into two or three periods, each with its own price, and your smart meter records which period every kWh fell into. The utility then bills on-peak kWh at the high price, off-peak kWh at the low price, and mid-peak kWh (if the plan has that tier) somewhere between. Fixed monthly charges, delivery riders and taxes sit on top exactly as they do on a flat plan, which matters when you compare offers: Con Edison's residential TOU, for example, carries a $21 monthly customer charge.
Most plans also change by season. The on-peak price is highest in the summer months the utility defines (June to September at Xcel Colorado and Georgia Power, May to October at APS), and some drop peak pricing entirely in winter. The Colorado PUC's description of Xcel's default residential TOU shows the whole structure in one place: 5 to 9 pm on non-holiday weekdays is on-peak at 21.277 cents per kWh in summer and 18.331 cents the rest of the year; every other hour is off-peak at 7.884 cents in summer and 6.792 cents otherwise. The PUC's own summary is that peak power costs 2.7 times the off-peak price, and that the peak block covers 344 hours of the summer and 664 hours of the other eight months, roughly 11.5% of the year.
The price ratio is the first thing to look at on any TOU offer. The Brattle Group's 2023 survey, Time-Varying Rates Are Moving from the Periphery to the Mainstream, found the peak price is at least double the off-peak price in 85% of two-period TOU rates, with a mean ratio near 3 to 1, and that Missouri's default TOU rates run as high as 4 or 5 to 1. A wider ratio means bigger rewards for shifting and bigger penalties for not shifting. The same paper recounts an early-2000s Puget Sound Energy rate with only a 30% differential where some customers saved 50 cents to a dollar a month, the opposite problem: a gap too small for anyone to bother shifting.
The plan types you will actually be offered
| Plan type | How the price changes | Example | Best suited to |
|---|---|---|---|
| Flat rate | One price per kWh at every hour | Most U.S. households; about 89% of customers were not on dynamic pricing in 2023 per FERC | Homes that cannot shift usage, or that want a predictable bill |
| Tiered rate | Price steps up once monthly usage passes a baseline, regardless of hour | PG&E's E-1 plan | Low-usage homes; timing does not matter |
| Two-period TOU | On-peak and off-peak prices | Xcel Colorado (5 to 9 pm weekdays), APS 4pm-7pm Weekdays, Georgia Power Nights & Weekends | Homes that can clear the one peak block |
| Three- or four-period TOU | Adds a mid-peak or shoulder tier, or a midday super-off-peak | SCE TOU-D-4-9PM (winter super-off-peak 8 am to 4 pm); ComEd Time-of-Day (Morning, Mid-Day Peak, Evening, Overnight) | Homes with flexible daytime loads, solar-heavy states |
| EV or electrification TOU | Very low overnight price, often no baseline credit, sometimes a credit for enrolling a vehicle | SCE TOU-D-PRIME (26 cents off-peak vs 61 cents summer on-peak); ComEd's $2 monthly EV credit for up to 24 months | EV owners, heat pump and battery households |
| Hourly or real-time pricing | Price changes every hour with the wholesale market | ComEd Hourly Pricing (separate from its Time-of-Day plan) | Highly flexible or automated homes willing to watch prices |
| Critical peak pricing or peak-time rebates | Normal pricing most days, a very high price (or a rebate for cutting back) on a handful of called event days | BGE's peak-time rebate, cited by Brattle for 15% to 20% event-day reductions | Anyone who can respond to a text on a hot afternoon |
Two tiers are easy to confuse. A tiered rate (PG&E's E-1, for instance) charges more once you pass a monthly kWh allowance, no matter when you used the power. A time-of-use rate charges more at certain hours, no matter how much you used. Some California plans combine both ideas through a baseline credit that lowers the price on your first block of kWh each month, which is why SCE lists every TOU price twice, before and after the credit.
Who saves on time-of-use rates, and who pays more
The pilots and rate studies agree that it depends on your load shape, and a utility that moves everyone onto TOU will produce winners and losers in the first month before anyone changes a habit. Brattle's survey states that time-varying rates "will definitely raise bills for customers whose load factors are lower than the average," meaning homes whose usage is concentrated in the expensive hours, while homes that already use a steady or off-peak-heavy pattern come out ahead without doing anything.
The clearest real-world numbers come from Maryland. Brattle's year-one evaluation of the PC44 time-of-use pilots at BGE, Pepco and Delmarva Power (June 2019 through May 2020) found participants cut their peak-period use by 10.2% to 14.8% in summer and 5.1% to 6.1% in the non-summer months, and saw average bill savings of 5% to 10%, including low- and moderate-income households. Older programs cited in the same Brattle survey range from 3% to 4% peak reductions in a Michigan pilot to 8% to 17% at the Arizona utilities and a 40% peak cut, with bills about 20% lower, in Oklahoma's variable-peak pricing program.
From those results and the price structures, the households that tend to gain are:
- EV owners. Charging is the single largest movable load in a home and it happens on a timer. Brattle notes EV owners on time-varying rates can cut their charging cost by more than half, and the EV-specific plans (SCE TOU-D-PRIME, ComEd's EV credit) are designed around it. Our EV home charging cost calculator will show the difference at your plan's two prices.
- Homes empty on weekday afternoons. If nobody is home from 1 to 7 pm, the peak block is already mostly empty on your meter.
- Homes with big loads on timers. Pool pumps, electric water heaters with timers, dishwashers and dryers with delay start, and smart thermostats that pre-cool before the peak and coast through it.
- Households in mild or solar-heavy climates, where the summer afternoon air conditioning load that drives peak bills is smaller, or where a midday super-off-peak block lines up with daytime use.
The households that tend to lose, at least until they change something:
- Homes with heavy weekday-afternoon air conditioning and no way to pre-cool or raise the setpoint during the peak. In a hot climate this is the biggest risk, and it is why APS's and SCE's summer peak prices are so much higher than their winter ones.
- Electric-heat homes on plans with a morning peak. EIA's load data shows a winter morning hump, and a plan that prices it will catch a heat pump or resistance heater working hardest at 7 am.
- Anyone who signs up and does nothing. Georgia Power says plainly that a customer who does not shift usage may see a higher bill on Nights & Weekends, and that the plan carries a 12-month commitment.
How to tell if switching pays: the peak-share calculation
You do not need a pilot study for your own house. You need one number, your peak share: the fraction of your monthly kWh that falls inside the proposed plan's on-peak window. Then:
TOU bill = total kWh × [ peak share × on-peak price + (1 − peak share) × off-peak price ]
Flat bill = total kWh × your current flat price
Break-even peak share = (flat price − off-peak price) ÷ (on-peak price − off-peak price). Below that share the TOU plan is cheaper; above it the flat plan is.
Getting the peak share takes a few minutes. Log in to your utility account and download hourly (or 15-minute) usage for a recent month, which nearly every smart-meter utility provides. Add up the kWh in the on-peak hours of the plan you are considering, divide by the month's total, and you have it. If your utility offers a rate comparison tool (ComEd's My Account has one, and SCE and PG&E publish rate plan comparisons), it is doing this same calculation on a full year of your data, which is better than one month because of the seasons.
Here is the arithmetic with real plan prices on a home using 863 kWh a month, the 2024 U.S. residential average from our average home usage guide. The on-peak and off-peak prices are APS's summer energy charges (34.396 and 12.345 cents per kWh, 4 to 7 pm weekdays), and the flat comparison is EIA's 18.23 cent national average forecast for this winter. This is an illustration of the method, not a comparison of two plans you can actually choose between: APS's prices exclude fees and riders, and the flat price you should use is the one on your own bill.
| Peak share | kWh in peak | TOU energy charge | Flat at 18.23¢ | TOU saves (costs) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 15% | 129 | $135.08 | $157.32 | $22.24 |
| 20% | 173 | $144.60 | $157.32 | $12.73 |
| 27% (break-even) | 233 | $157.92 | $157.32 | ($0.59) |
| 30% | 259 | $163.63 | $157.32 | ($6.30) |
| 40% | 345 | $182.66 | $157.32 | ($25.33) |
| 50% | 432 | $201.69 | $157.32 | ($44.36) |
The break-even for this pair of prices is (18.23 − 12.345) ÷ (34.396 − 12.345) = 26.7%. The 4 to 7 pm weekday window is only 15 of the week's 168 hours, about 9%, so a home that uses electricity at an even pace all week would sit near 9% peak share and save about $34 a month at these prices. A home that runs the air conditioner and the oven in exactly those hours could sit at 30% or 40% and pay more. The wider the price ratio, the lower the break-even share and the more the answer depends on your habits; at Georgia Power's 30.3 and 7.8 cents the break-even against the same flat price is 46%, because the off-peak price is so low. Run your own numbers through the kWh cost calculator twice, once at each price, and compare the sum to your current bill's energy charges.
Watch the fixed charges. The formula above compares energy charges only. If the TOU plan has a higher monthly customer charge (Con Edison's is $21), add the difference to the TOU side before deciding. And check the seasons: a plan that looks great in April can look different in August, when summer peak prices apply (Georgia Power has no peak pricing at all until June).
Default, optional, and how to opt out
Whether you get to choose at all depends on where you live. In Colorado, Xcel's residential customers were moved to the TOU rate by default between 2022 and 2025 under a plan approved by the state PUC. In California, the Public Utilities Commission's residential rate reform set default time-of-use pricing, with an optional tiered rate, as the target structure for PG&E, SCE and SDG&E, which is why a California bill usually shows a TOU plan unless the household chose otherwise. Illinois is the opposite: ComEd's Time-of-Day pricing is opt-in, with no cost to enroll or cancel, though a change takes two to three billing cycles to show up. Georgia Power's Nights & Weekends is optional but asks for a 12-month commitment, and Con Edison lets customers who enrolled before March 2014 keep their original hours. Con Edison also asks new enrollees to stay on the plan for a year, and a customer who switches back to the standard rate has to wait 18 months to rejoin.
If you are defaulted onto a TOU plan and your bill goes up, the first call is to ask the utility for its flat or tiered alternative and whether a bill comparison or first-year bill protection is available; many default rollouts include one. If you are weighing an optional plan, ask three questions before enrolling: the exact hours and season dates, the minimum term and exit rule, and whether the utility will run the comparison on your last twelve months of interval data. A utility that offers the plan should be able to tell you what you would have paid last year on it.
Making a TOU plan pay once you are on it
Everything in the pilot results points the same way: the savings come from a few automated changes rather than from remembering to wait. Set the EV charger to start when off-peak begins and let it finish before the morning. Use the delay-start button on the dishwasher and the washer so cycles run in the cheap block, and run the dryer in the morning or at night. Put the pool pump on a timer that avoids the peak entirely; it only needs a set number of hours a day, not particular ones. If you have a smart thermostat, pre-cool the house by a couple of degrees in the hour before the peak starts and let it drift up by a few degrees during the peak; in a hot climate the thermostat is the biggest single lever, because air conditioning is what fills the peak block in the first place. An electric water heater on a timer can heat the tank overnight and coast through the afternoon.
What not to bother with: lights, the refrigerator, the router and the TV you are actually watching. They cannot move, they are not large, and the time you spend worrying about them is better spent setting one timer on a big load. For a per-appliance list of what each shift is worth in cents, see is electricity cheaper at night?, and for the live peak windows at the major utilities, the peak and off-peak hours guide. Our guide to energy monitors and smart plugs covers the plug-in timers and whole-home monitors that make the shifting automatic and show you your peak share in real time.
This guide was written by Cedrick Reese for ElectricityUsageCalculator.com. The savings and peak-reduction figures come from published evaluations (the Brattle Group's Maryland PC44 pilot evaluation and its 2023 survey of time-varying rates) and from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission's 2025 demand response assessment, not from estimates; the plan prices in the worked example are APS's and Georgia Power's published energy charges and the Colorado PUC's summary of Xcel's rate, with the 18.23 cent flat comparison taken from EIA's October 2026 Winter Fuels Outlook. The break-even table was calculated from those inputs with the formula shown on the page, so you can reproduce every row. Utility prices and hours are rechecked against the linked rate pages each spring and fall, and whenever a utility announces new prices. Last checked November 2026.
Related tools and guides
- Peak and Off-Peak Electricity Hours: When They Are and What They Cost
- Is Electricity Cheaper at Night? What Running Appliances Off-Peak Saves
- kWh Cost Calculator
- EV Home Charging Cost Calculator
- Electricity Bill Calculator
- How Much Does Electricity Cost?
Sources
- Brattle Group, PC44 Time-of-Use Pilots: Year One Evaluation (September 2020)
- Faruqui and Tang (Brattle), Time-Varying Rates Are Moving from the Periphery to the Mainstream (August 2023, draft chapter)
- FERC, 2025 Assessment of Demand Response and Advanced Metering (December 2025)
- Colorado Public Utilities Commission, Time of Use Rates (hours effective November 1, 2025)
- APS, Time-of-Use 4pm-7pm Weekdays
- Georgia Power, Nights & Weekends
- Southern California Edison, Time-of-Use Residential Rate Plans
- PG&E, Residential Electric Rate Plan Pricing (effective March 1, 2026)
- Con Edison, Time-of-Use Rates
- ComEd, Time-of-Day Pricing announcement (July 23, 2026)
- California Public Utilities Commission, Residential Rate Reform (R.12-06-013)
- EIA, Winter Fuels Outlook (October 2026)
- EIA, Hourly electricity consumption varies throughout the day and across seasons (February 2020)
The worked example uses published energy charges from named utilities and a national average flat price purely to demonstrate the method. It is not a recommendation to enroll in or leave any plan. Your utility's rate comparison on your own interval data is the figure to act on.